5 tips to be the most effective manager and retain top talent

What’s the number-one reason employees quit? It’s not usually money. It’s the work environment, and more specifically, their manager.

People don’t leave companies; they leave managers who fail to create a workplace where they feel valued, challenged and supported. If you want to retain top talent, focus on creating a culture that motivates, engages and fulfills your team.

Here are five practical ways to be the kind of manager people want to work for:

1. Make the work stimulating

People thrive when they’re solving real problems, not just checking boxes. Give them challenges that stretch their skills and make the work feel meaningful.

Try this: Rotate responsibilities, assign stretch projects, or involve them in cross-functional efforts. When employees see how their work contributes to bigger goals, their engagement deepens.

2. Empower people to own their work

Autonomy builds engagement. Trust your team to make decisions, even if they occasionally make mistakes. When employees feel ownership, they take more initiative and pride in their work.

Try this: Let them propose solutions, lead meetings or run with their ideas. Empowerment sends a message: “I trust you to lead.”

3. Protect your team from burnout

Overloading your top performers because “they don’t complain” is a fast track to losing them. Even your best employees have limits, and burnout often shows up silently, until it’s too late. Keep workloads fair and sustainable, especially during times of change or after layoffs.

Try this: Make it safe for employees to say “I’m at capacity.” Regularly check workloads, and don’t reward silence with more assignments. 

4. Ask employees what they need and listen

You don’t have to guess what your employees need. Ask them directly: What’s working? What’s getting in the way? Regular check-ins help you catch issues before they become resignation letters.

Try this: Use stay interviews, not just exit interviews, to understand how to retain your best people. A few well-placed questions can uncover roadblocks or opportunities you didn’t know existed. Ask:

• “Which parts of your role feel most meaningful and which feel like a drain?”
• “What’s one thing that would make your experience here better?”
• “Have you ever thought about leaving, and if so, what made you consider it?”

5. Show appreciation often

Recognition is free, and it’s one of the most powerful retention tools you have. A genuine “thank you” or “great job” goes further than most bonuses or perks. Don’t save praise for performance reviews; give it when it’s earned.

Try this: Tailor your appreciation to the person; some love public recognition, others prefer a private word of thanks or a quick note. When people feel seen, they stay invested.

No manager can eliminate turnover, but great managers reduce it dramatically. And when someone does leave, don’t let the lesson walk out the door with them. 

Every departure is an opportunity to strengthen your culture and leadership. Because in the end, leadership isn’t about preventing exits, it’s about creating a workplace people don’t want to leave.

Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.

____________________________________

Take advantage of SmartBrief’s FREE email newsletters on leadership and business transformation, among the company’s more than 250 industry-focused newsletters.