American City to Pay $500,000 After Police Officer Fatally Shoots Blind & Deaf Dog “Teddy”
The city of Sturgeon, Missouri, has agreed to pay a $500,000 settlement to the owner of Teddy, a blind and deaf Shih Tzu who was fatally shot by a police officer earlier this year. This incident has led to discussions about animal rights, police training, and how officers handle vulnerable pets.
Details of the Incident
The incident occurred in May 2024, when Officer Myron Woodson responded to a report about a “dog at large.” Teddy, a small 13-pound Shih Tzu with severe disabilities, had wandered onto a neighborhood lawn. Body-camera footage later revealed how the situation unfolded: the officer attempted to capture Teddy using a snare pole but struggled to do so.
Shortly after, the officer drew his firearm and shot Teddy at close range. The body-camera footage recorded the gunshot. When the video was shared online, it sparked public anger and calls for changes to police procedures.
Teddy’s owner, Nicholas Hunter, described his beloved pet as harmless and gentle, emphasizing that Teddy’s blindness and deafness made him extremely vulnerable. The idea that a disabled, non-aggressive dog could be perceived as a threat further fueled public disbelief.
The Settlement: What It Means
After filing a lawsuit against the city, Hunter and his legal team reached a settlement in which $282,500 will go directly to him, while $217,500 will cover legal fees. As part of the agreement, Hunter waived any future claims related to Teddy’s death.
The lawsuit highlighted problems in Sturgeon’s police training, particularly in how officers handle animals. It argued that Teddy’s death happened because of a lack of proper procedures.
Officer’s Defense and Official Response
Officer Woodson defended his actions by saying he believed Teddy was a stray and appeared to be injured. According to his affidavit, he acted under the city’s existing police policy, which allows officers to put down an animal if it is injured to the point of suffering or poses a threat.
Critics said that Teddy did not show aggression in the video. Animal welfare experts said that the officer should have been more careful because Teddy was disabled.
The public outcry that followed the release of the footage was intense. In the aftermath, Sturgeon’s mayor resigned, and the city faced strong demands to overhaul its animal-handling procedures and reinforce humane training practices for its officers.
Broader Implications for Animal Welfare
This incident has shown that many small police departments lack adequate training to handle domestic animals. Officers often respond to calls about stray animals without enough guidance or training.
Animal welfare organizations have stressed that tragedies like Teddy’s can be prevented. They recommend mandatory training programs to teach officers how to safely approach pets, especially those with disabilities or who are scared. What followed could push more cities to invest in better training and stricter policies. It also serves as a reminder that pets, even small and disabled ones, are often treated as threats due to misjudgment or fear.
Ongoing Effects of the Case
For Teddy’s owner, the settlement does not replace the loss of his pet. For the community, Teddy’s story shows why compassion, training, and accountability are important in policing, both for people and for pets who rely on humans.
Teddy’s death may lead to changes that help prevent similar incidents in the future.
