Continuing with my focus on fantasy this month, I wanted to jump in and discuss the age-old debate: Is the book better than the movie? Although I love a good book and can be found with a book on me most of the time. I also love a great movie. I am a sucker for a book that has been made into a movie and when choosing what to watch, if the film has been adapted from a book it moves up my list of priorities to watch. This time, I’ve chosen to take a closer look at Nightbitch to discuss one of my favourite questions: Is the Book better than the movie? This surreal and darkly humorous story has captured attention in both literary and cinematic worlds, making it the perfect candidate for my book versus movie discussion.
-
Title: Nightbitch
-
Author: Rachel Yoder
-
Genre: Fantasy
-
Publisher: Vintage
-
Date Published: 2022
-
Book Length: 256 pages
One day, the mother was a mother, but then, one night, she was quite suddenly something else…
At home full-time with her two-year-old son, an artist finds herself struggling. She is lonely, exhausted, and disconnected from her former self. Her husband, always away for work, calls from distant hotel rooms, leaving her to manage the chaos of motherhood alone. As her sense of self starts to fray, something extraordinary happens. One night, when her child refuses to sleep, she discovers new appetites, instincts, and a voice emerging from deep within her. Is she losing her mind or transforming into something utterly feral?
Nightbitch is a fiercely original exploration of the raw, unfiltered experiences of motherhood. Rachel Yoder captures the mundane struggles of caregiving with an uncanny twist, blending humour, horror, and heartbreak. The book’s fantastical elements serve as a metaphor for the primal nature of motherhood, making it both deeply relatable and profoundly unsettling. At 256 pages, it’s a quick yet impactful read that leaves a lasting impression.
Yoder’s writing is sharp, evocative, and unflinchingly honest. While the surreal narrative may not be for everyone, those who embrace its wildness will find it a transformative reading experience.
-
Title: Nightbitch
-
Director: Marielle Heller
-
Writers: Marielle Heller, Rachel Yoder
-
Stars: Amy Adams, Scoot McNairy, Arleigh Snowden
-
Release Date: 2024
The movie adaptation of Nightbitch follows a woman who, confined to the stay-at-home routine of raising a toddler in the suburbs, begins to embrace the feral power of motherhood. As she becomes increasingly aware of bizarre and undeniable signs that she may be turning into a dog, her journey takes on a surreal, primal edge.
With Marielle Heller at the helm and the incomparable Amy Adams in the lead role, the Nightbitch movie brings Rachel Yoder’s vision to life in a striking new way. Adams’s nuanced performance captures the slow unravelling and fierce transformation of the protagonist. Heller’s direction adds a visual richness, using unsettling imagery and poignant moments to mirror the book’s dark humour and raw emotion.
However, like many adaptations, some elements of the book’s deeper introspection are lost in translation. While the film excels in creating a visceral, cinematic experience, it might not delve as deeply into the protagonist’s internal conflict as the novel does.
Book vs. Movie: The Differences
The book and movie both tackle the same core themes—motherhood, identity, and transformation—but they do so in distinct ways. The book leans heavily into the surreal and introspective, allowing readers to fully inhabit the protagonist’s psyche. Rachel Yoder’s prose paints a vivid picture of the exhaustion and primal instincts of motherhood, with plenty of room for personal interpretation.
The movie, on the other hand, translates these themes into a more visual medium. Amy Adams’s performance anchors the story, bringing a human vulnerability to the surreal premise. The film simplifies some of the book’s complexities for a broader audience, which may disappoint purist fans of the novel but could make the story more accessible to newcomers.
One major difference is the pacing. The book’s slower, more introspective pace contrasts with the film’s tighter, more dramatic narrative structure. Additionally, the movie places greater emphasis on the protagonist’s external transformation, with striking visual effects that highlight her feral descent.
Conclusion: Which Is Better?
So, which version reigns supreme? It depends on what you’re looking for. If you want a deeply personal, thought-provoking experience that explores the psychological depths of motherhood, the book is your best bet. Rachel Yoder’s prose invites readers into the raw, unfiltered chaos of the protagonist’s mind, offering a uniquely intimate experience.
If, however, you prefer a fast-paced, visually stunning interpretation with a powerhouse performance by Amy Adams, the movie delivers in spades. Marielle Heller’s direction and the cinematic medium bring a visceral immediacy to the story that’s hard to replicate in text.
For me, the book edges out slightly ahead because of its sheer originality and emotional depth. But both versions offer something special, making Nightbitch a compelling story no matter how you choose to experience it.
Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you and helps support the content I create. Thank you from the bottom of my heart.
