Recommended for: Those who crave feminist horror, Southern Gothic atmospheres, and stories that unflinchingly examine the cost of power.
I’ve read a lot of new books this year, but this is probably my favourite. Dark, haunting, and powerfully evocative, Witchcraft for Wayward Girls is a masterful blend of Southern Gothic horror and feminist storytelling that lingers long after the final page. With its vivid setting, morally complex characters, and a narrative steeped in dread and longing, this novel is nothing short of spellbinding.
The story follows fifteen-year-old Fern as she arrives at the oppressive Wellwood House in the sweltering summer of 1970. A home for “wayward girls”—a cruel euphemism for unwed mothers hidden away by their families—Wellwood is a place of secrecy and shame, where every moment is controlled by those who claim to know what’s best. Fern’s fear and isolation are palpable, and the other girls—from defiant Rose to enigmatic Holly—add layers of tension and camaraderie to the tale.
The setting is a character in its own right, with the stifling Florida heat and the claustrophobic atmosphere of Wellwood perfectly mirroring the girls’ desperation. It’s a place where hope is scarce, and the rules are unyielding… until Fern discovers an occult book that shifts the balance of power. The introduction of witchcraft is handled brilliantly, offering the girls a taste of agency but at a terrible cost. The escalating tension as they wield their newfound power is both thrilling and terrifying.
What sets this novel apart is its emotional depth. Fern’s journey is as much about reclaiming her identity and confronting the societal expectations placed upon her as it is about the supernatural. The friendships she forms and the choices she’s forced to make are deeply affecting. And the book’s exploration of power—who holds it, who seeks it, and the price of taking it—is as relevant as ever.
The prose is rich and atmospheric, drawing readers into a world that feels both otherworldly and all too real. The supporting cast is equally compelling, with each girl’s backstory adding texture to the narrative. And while the story doesn’t shy away from the darkness, it’s also infused with moments of defiance, resilience, and even hope.
Witchcraft for Wayward Girls is a triumph of storytelling, blending horror, history, and heart into an unforgettable tale. This is a book that demands a sequel. Fern’s story is complete yet leaves the door tantalisingly ajar for further exploration of the dark forces she’s unleashed. Here’s hoping we return to this world—and its wayward girls—soon.
‘Witchcraft for Wayward Girls’ is due to be published on 16th January 2024.
Thank you to NetGalley UK, Grady Hendrix and Pan MacMillan for an ARC of this novel in exchange for my honest review.
