Is the RRSP for Life Worth It?


Is the RRSP for Life Worth It?

Interesting news of late: Canada’s latest federal budget proposed a tweak to Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) aimed at simplifying financial planning – so I wondered, is this a gimmick or is having an RRSP for Life worth it?

Read on. 🙂

RRSP 101

I won’t repeat, in detail, all the ins and outs of the RRSP. 

You can find that here:

Tax Deferred Investing – RRSPs 101

For years, we used our respective RRSPs for the following benefits as part of our own retirement planning:

  1. a tax deduction today, when working, from our RRSP contributions, and
  2. tax deferred growth.

With your tax deduction, you can reduce the taxes you pay today. We did that.

With tax deferred growth, investments in your RRSP can compound over time without being taxed as long as money made stays in the account. We also enjoyed that and still do. 

So, the RRSP is an investment account (a point in bold I will come back to later…not just savings) that lowers your tax exposure today, and lets your investments grow without being taxed until you retire. Your RRSP can hold a wide variety of financial assets, including cash, stocks, guaranteed investment certificates (GICs), and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). 

What are the proposed RRSP for Life changes?

Currently, RRSPs must be withdrawn or converted into a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) in the year the account holder turns 71.

Well, in the latest federal budget, our government proposes to allow Canadians to *keep their RRSPs after they reach that age. *Mininum RRSP/RRIF withdrawal rates would still exist. 

Currently, if someone dies after age 71 with a RRIF, the account can be transferred to a spouse without closing it or triggering tax paperwork. That’s not the case today with RRSPs. 

The new budget proposal would allow a surviving spouse or partner to become a successor holder of an RRSP, and simplify tax-free transfers to qualified survivors after the death of the account holder.

So, the proposal is positive overall with some key facts to be mindful of:

  • Mandatory Withdrawals Remain: Even though the proposal eliminates the requirement to formally convert an RRSP into a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) at age 71, minimum annual withdrawals still start the year after you turn 71.
  • Tax Status Unchanged: Every dollar withdrawn under the mandatory minimum rules remains fully taxable as income.
  • There is an Administrative Shift: The primary changes focus on simplifying paperwork, merging RRSP and RRIF tax rules, and allowing a spouse or common-law partner to be named a “successor holder” for an RRSP (similar to TFSAs).

Beneficiaries for TFSAs, RRSPs, RRIFs and other key accounts

Good news, overall, but this proposal does not go nearly as far I would have liked. 

The government continues to have a significant gaps to demystify and therefore simplify the RRSP structure. 

Why do any changes to the RRSP rules, matter?

First, the praise. 

  • The proposal to allow RRSPs to be easily transferred after death is just common sense for those that have partners. 
  • The proposal aligns with the real-world, most 70-somethings are already converting their RRSPs to RRIFs for retirement income, if not sooner, triggering annual withdrawals and paying back tax. Under the proposed change, the government would require RRSP holders to withdraw a minimum percentage of their savings each year, starting at age 72 – just like a RRIF does.

Some tax and personal finance experts say while the new “RRSP for life” concept is an improvement I think the government has missed an opportunity here – to get rid of the RRIF and all mininum withdrawal rules altogether.

I propose the following changes that could really matter to demystify and simplify retirement income planning for everyone:

  • Remove All Mandatory Withdrawals: Get rid of the RRIF concept altogether which includes requirements for all mandatory withdrawals on any prescribed schedule. Simple:
    • You have an RRSP which is a tax-deferred account, you haven’t paid tax on the growth or withdrawals yet. 
    • When any RRSP money comes out, it is taxed as income. Withholding taxes may apply. 
    • When and how much you decide to take out of your RRSP is your cashflow decision. Just like non-registered accounts and TFSAs. There are no mandatory withdrawal rules for those accounts. There is no mandatory age limit on those accounts either!

I do not need the governement to be in the business of managing my personal cashflow.

  • RRSP Tax Status Unchanged: Every dollar withdrawn from your RRSP, in any year, at any time, is fully taxable as income. Simple. 
  • There is an Administrative Shift with Life and Death: I don’t mind the RRSP “successor holder” concept but go further – change the name of the RRSP; get rid of the “savings” concept as part of this account, as you get rid of the RRIF entirely. 
    • Call the RRSP what it is: A Tax-Deferred Retirement Account (TDRA) or something equivalent.

Back in 2013, I struggled with some account names. I proposed some changes myself. 

Name Changes Needed to Canadian Financial Accounts

I wrote:

“I think Canadian investors should be motivated to better understand the tax implications of using various accounts in order to best utilize them for their saving and retirement goals.”

I still feel that way more than a decade later! 🙂

My other proposals, some might be controversial:

  • Remove the pension income splitting rules – gasp! Right now, RRIF withdrawals qualify for pension income splitting after age 65 whereas any RRSP withdrawals don’t. Either way, any income splitting is unfair to folks that don’t have spouses or partners – it unfairly penalizes singles in retirement which has always annoyed me. So, I would in a controversial way for some propose to:
    • remove these pension income splitting benefits that only benefit couples, which also,
    • removes the required RRIF payments based on either your own age, or that of your spouse. Keep it simple: any RRSP withdrawals are taxed to the annuitant.
  • Keep Spousal RRSPs. For couples, I don’t mind Spousal RRSPs and keeping them is a form of income splitting – you can be strategic in how much the lower-income spouse has or does not have in their RRSP eventually. Again, since any RRSP withdrawals are taxed to the annuitant you can be strategic in your asset accumlation years: how much to contribute to the Spousal RRSP or not at all. Recall the higher-income spouse can contribute to lower their current taxation and the lower-earning spouse is the legal owner of the account. When funds are eventually withdrawn, they are taxed to them. Finally, related to this, I would remove any spousal attribution rule – it’s currently 3-years but why not 2-years or 5-years? I get this is to avoid tax-washing but there is a contribution limit for personal RRSP contributions that includes the personal room for Spousal RRSPs to prevent too much of this – so keep RRSP contribution limits based on earned income. Simplify and reduce complexity with all RRSP rules. 

You may wonder about the lack of income splitting which is controversial maybe, well, here is my thinking on that:

  • Unfairness to Single Seniors. Single, widowed, and divorced retirees cannot split their RRSP/RRIF income with anyone yet they face higher per-person living costs (such as housing and utilities) than couples who share expenses. I don’t believe our tax system should give just married couples a substantial tax break that single seniors cannot access.
  • Disproportionate Benefit to Higher Income Earners. Couples where both partners earned similar, modest incomes receive almost no benefit from RRSP income splitting. The biggest tax savings for folks that use Spousal RRSPs go to very high-income earners including couples who can take advantage of the Spousal RRSP. I don’t believe our tax system should give too many more benefits to higher-income individuals or households that lower-income individuals or couples cannot utilize equally. 

I have some other ideas but these are the big ones, basically make “RRSPs for Life” more simplified mirror-images of the TFSA:

“RRSP for Life” Concept

TFSA

A tax-deferral plan. A tax-free plan.
Contributions can be made with “before-tax” dollars. Contributions can be made with “after-tax” dollars.

 

Contributions are tax deductible; you will get a refund roughly equal to the amount of multiplying your contribution by your tax rate. Contributions are not tax deductible; there is no refund to be had.
If you don’t contribute your maximum allowable amount in any given year you can carry forward contribution room, up to your limit.
If you make a withdrawal, contribution room is lost. If you make a withdrawal, amounts withdrawn create an equal amount of contribution room you can re-contribute the following year.
Because contributions were not taxed when they were made (you got a refund), contributions and investment earnings inside the plan are taxable upon withdrawal.  Because contributions were taxed (there was no refund), contributions and investing earnings inside the account are tax exempt upon withdrawal.
Since withdrawals are treated as income, withdrawals could reduce retirement government benefits. Withdrawals are not considered taxable income, so government income-tested benefits and tax credits such as the GST Credit, Old Age Security (OAS) and the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) aren’t affected by withdrawals.

Accounts have no upper age limit.

When and how much you decide to take out of your RRSP is your cashflow decision.

The government will eventually get their money based on your withdrawals or death if you don’t spend it. 

Accounts have no upper age limit. 

When and how much you decide to take out of your TFSA is your cashflow decision.

The government has already taxed your money. 

The Summary: part of your RRSP is borrowed money. The Summary: all of your TFSA is your money.

Is the RRSP for Life Worth It?

Yes. 

I agree with the proposal and where it’s going but I would prefer the government take a bigger swing: undo the bureaucracy associated with the RRSP while killing off the RRIF structure and rules at the same time.

I want my government to be in the business of streamlining and simplifying our tax system for Canadian tax payers – something they should be striving to do all along. 

Mark

Footnote: Public consultation is now open on this issue. Have your say.

Budget 2026 notes that the proposed combination of the RRSP and RRIF regimes requires further analysis.  The Government has expressed a desire to obtain stakeholder input on the combination proposal.  Interested parties may submit written representations to the Department of Finance prior to January 8, 2027 by email at [email protected]. I will be sharing this link with them and you can do the same.  🙂

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Som2ny Network
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart