Compare website analytics tools using your own data – Analytics Platform


You rely on your web analytics to check website traffic, visitor behaviour and conversions. But how do you know whether your current analytics platform is giving you the full picture? 

One way to investigate is to run a second analytics platform alongside your existing one and compare what both report about the same website. You might find differences in visits, pageviews or conversions, even when both tools are working correctly. Tracking methods, settings and metric definitions can all affect the results. For example, Matomo’s visit rules differ from GA4’s session rules. 

We’ll use Google Analytics 4 (GA4) and Matomo to show you how to compare reports, investigate differences and understand what your existing analytics captures. 

Can you run two analytics tools on the same website? 

Yes, in most cases. Web analytics platforms can generally run alongside each other on the same website. Each tool uses its own tracking setup to collect and report data, so adding a second platform usually doesn’t require you to switch off your existing one. 

The exact setup depends on the tools you’re using and how tracking is implemented on your website. For example, Matomo supports running alongside Google Analytics and other analytics platforms. 

PerformRomance and Worldsites GmbH took this approach, running GA4 and Matomo side by side for 11 days. They’ll share the results and lessons from their experiment in our free webinar on 1 December 2026. 

Before you start comparing results, there are three things worth checking. 

1. Make sure both tools are tracking correctly 

Check that both platforms collect data from the same pages and that any conversions you want to compare, such as form submissions or purchases, are configured in both. 

Also, check that you haven’t accidentally installed the same tracking code twice, for example through both your website and a tag manager. This can lead to duplicate pageviews or conversions. 

2. Check your consent setup 

Both analytics platforms need to respect the privacy requirements that apply to your website. Check how your consent management platform handles each tool and what happens when visitors accept or reject analytics tracking. 

3. Check whether page performance is affected 

Adding another browser-based analytics tool means additional code for your visitors’ browsers to load and run. This can affect page performance, depending on how the tools are implemented. 

You can check the impact using Google Lighthouse in Chrome. Run a mobile performance test with your existing tool, then repeat it with both tools active. Use the same page, settings and consent choices, and run each test three times to reduce the impact of natural variation. 

Compare the middle readings for Largest Contentful Paint (when the largest visible content appears) and Total Blocking Time (how long the browser is blocked from responding during loading). 

Once both platforms are collecting data correctly, you can start comparing what their reports tell you about your website. 

Compare your analytics results in four steps 

Once both tools are collecting data, follow these four steps to compare their reports and investigate any differences you find. 

1. Decide what you want to compare 

Start with the questions you rely on your analytics to answer. How much traffic does your website receive? Where do visitors come from? And how many complete important actions, such as submitting a contact form or making a purchase? 

Focus on a few areas that matter to your website. For a comparison between GA4 and Matomo, you could start with: 

  • Website traffic: How many visits or sessions each platform records during the same period. 
  • Pageviews: How often visitors view specific pages on your website. 
  • Traffic sources: How traffic is distributed across channels such as organic search, paid campaigns and referrals. 
  • Conversions: How often each platform records a specific action, such as a contact form submission. 

Starting with a manageable set of figures makes it easier to spot differences, investigate their causes and understand how each platform measures your website activity. 

2. Check that both platforms are measuring under comparable conditions 

Before comparing the numbers, make sure both platforms are measuring under comparable conditions. Otherwise, differences in your reports might come from your tracking setup rather than the platforms’ measurement methods. 

Check the following: 

  • Reporting period: Are you comparing the same dates and time zones? Choose a period with enough traffic and conversions to make the comparison meaningful. If your website records relatively few conversions, you may need to observe both platforms for longer. Allow time for recent data to finish processing before comparing the reports. 
  • Tracked pages and interactions: Do both tools track the same pages and actions? Check that important interactions, such as form submissions, are recorded in both. 
  • Consent configuration: Does each platform collect data from the same visitors? For example, one tool might require consent while another uses a configuration that qualifies for a consent exemption under applicable law. Keep in mind that consent-exempt configurations may also limit which information a platform collects, particularly for marketing and campaign measurement. 
  • Conversion configuration: Are both platforms measuring the same actions, and do they use the same rules for counting conversions? 

The configurations don’t have to be identical. Document any differences that could affect the comparison, and don’t change a compliant tracking setup simply to make the figures match. 

Once you’ve checked these conditions, you’ll have a better understanding of which figures you can compare directly and where you need to account for differences in configuration. 

3. Compare equivalent metrics 

Even when two analytics platforms measure the same website activity, they may define and calculate their metrics differently. Make sure you’re comparing the closest equivalents before interpreting the numbers. 

For GA4 and Matomo, these are useful starting points: 

What to compare Matomo Google Analytics 4 What to check
Website traffic  Visits  Sessions  Rules for starting and ending a visit or session 
Pageviews  Pageviews  Views (web pages)  What triggers a pageview 
Conversions  Goal conversions  Key events  Conversion definitions and counting methods 
Traffic sources  Acquisition > All Channels  Acquisition > Traffic acquisition  Channel classifications and attribution rules 

Visits and sessions, for example, both use a 30-minute inactivity timeout by default. However, Matomo also starts a new visit when someone continues browsing after midnight or arrives through a different campaign. GA4 uses different session rules, so the same visitor activity can produce different totals. 

Conversions provide another example. Matomo counts each Goal once per visit by default, while GA4 generally counts every occurrence of a key event. If someone submits the same form twice during one visit, Matomo could report one Goal conversion and GA4 two key events, depending on their configuration. 

Understanding these differences helps you interpret the figures and recognise when a discrepancy comes from how the platforms calculate their metrics. 

4. Investigate differences before drawing conclusions 

Once you’ve compared the figures, look more closely at where they differ. For example, does one platform consistently report fewer visits? Do pageview counts differ only for certain pages? Or are the discrepancies concentrated in specific traffic sources? 

  • Tracking implementation: If one tool records fewer pageviews on particular pages, check whether its tracking code runs correctly on those pages. Missing or duplicate tracking can affect the numbers. 
  • Consent and tracking restrictions: If one platform consistently reports less traffic, review when each tool is allowed to collect data. Consent settings, browser restrictions and tracking blockers can affect how many visits are recorded. 
  • Bot filtering: If traffic totals differ significantly or one platform shows unusual spikes, check how each handles automated activity. GA4 automatically excludes known bots and spiders, while Matomo also provides spam and bot filtering. Different filtering rules can affect the results. 
  • Traffic sources and attribution: If organic, paid or direct traffic figures differ, check how each platform groups traffic sources. For example, a campaign might appear under different channel categories in Matomo and GA4. Compare individual sources or campaigns rather than assuming the channel totals are directly equivalent. Attribution rules can also affect which channels receive credit for conversions. 
  • Data processing and modelling: Check whether GA4 has applied sampling, data thresholds or modelling to the reports you’re comparing. Depending on its configuration, GA4 can include estimated data alongside observed activity. Matomo doesn’t sample its reports. Understanding these differences helps you interpret what the reported figures represent. 

For more details, see Matomo’s guide to why its reports differ from Google Analytics and other tools. 

Investigate one discrepancy at a time, starting with the pages, channels or conversions that matter most to you. Understanding why the figures differ will help you assess what each platform captures and how much confidence to place in its reports. 

What can the comparison tell you about your current analytics? 

Once you’ve investigated the discrepancies, consider what each finding means for your current analytics and whether you need to take action. 

  • Differences in measurement: If both platforms record similar activity but calculate metrics differently, neither result is automatically wrong. Understanding those differences helps you interpret your reports correctly. 
  • Tracking problems: If you’ve found missing pageviews, incorrectly configured conversions or other implementation issues, you can address them and check whether the results improve. 
  • Potential gaps in your data: If one platform consistently records activity that the other misses, investigate why. You can also compare relevant figures against other sources, such as form submissions in your CRM or completed orders in your ecommerce system. Keep differences in counting methods, consent and tracking restrictions in mind. 

Document what you’ve found, including any issues you’ve resolved and differences you still can’t explain. This helps you decide which figures you can rely on, where additional checks are needed and whether your current setup provides the information you need. 

A comparison won’t establish the exact amount of activity on your website. It can, however, help you understand how your data is collected, recognise potential gaps and make better-informed decisions based on your analytics. 

See what happened when GA4 and Matomo ran side by side for 11 days 

Different analytics results can lead to different conclusions about which marketing channels perform best and where to invest your budget. But what happens when two platforms measure the same website? 

On 1 December 2026, PerformRomance and Worldsites GmbH will join Matomo to share findings from their 11-day comparison of GA4 and Matomo, including where the numbers differed and what those differences could mean for marketing decisions. 

Join the free webinar to hear directly from the people behind the experiment and learn what to consider when assessing your own analytics data. 

Register for the free webinar: Can you trust the data behind your marketing decisions? What GA4 vs Matomo reveals 

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Som2ny Network
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart